For complete access
Get full access to Ratings and recommendations on appliances, cars & trucks, electronic gear, and much more.  today to ConsumerReports.org.
October 2007
send to a friend printable version
A look at three types of air purifiers


Inside an ionizing air cleaner

Unlike HEPA air cleaners, shown at bottom, electrostatic precipitator air purifiers impart an electrical charge to the air, creating charged molecules known as ions, which are supposed to cling to airborne particles. Electrostatic precipitators add an oppositely charged collection plate or filter designed to attract the particles. Ozone is produced as a byproduct, which then exits the machine and flows into the room air.

Ionizing air cleaner.
Ozone is created as high voltage converts oxygen to ozone. All electrostatic precipitators can create ozone, though some emit more than others. Some people mistake ozone's sweet smell for a sign of cleaner air.
Illustrations by Trevor Johnston  



Inside a HEPA air cleaner


HEPA air cleaner.
Models with a high-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filter are most common. Typically, a fan pulls air through a foam pre-filter designed to remove some larger particles. The air is then forced through the pleated HEPA filter, which is designed to trap most particles. The air might then pass through a carbon filter to remove odors. Sometimes the carbon filter will take the place of the pre-filter.
 



Inside an ozone generator



Room air passes through a high-voltage plate, where some oxygen molecules are ionized. The ions combine with oxygen to form ozone. The size of the generating plate and the amount of electrical current will affect the amount of ozone produced. Generally, ozone generators emit high levels of ozone, so they are not meant for routine air cleaning. They should be used only by professionals in unoccupied areas after serious contamination has occurred in the home, say from a fire or a flood.