Best & worst

Last reviewed: May 2010

Nonstick cookware

Earth Pan with Sand Flow and Mercola Healthy Chef nonstick cookware
Earth Pan with Sand Flow and
Mercola Healthy Chef nonstick cookware
The 10-piece Earth Pan with Sand Flow, $190, at left, delivered high performance at half the price of some other sets we tested. Burned food, handles that broke during testing, and stuck-on food helped land the $300 Mercola Healthy Chef cookware set at the bottom of our Ratings.
 

Showerheads

Moen Inspire 21777 and Price Pfister Bell 15-070 showerheads
Moen Inspire 21777 and
Price Pfister Bell 15-070 showerheads
Moen's top-rated Inspire 21777, at left, offered a strong flow of water at a consistent temperature and seven settings. Even the $50 price is appealing. But pass up the $40 Price Pfister Bell 15-070. A big drop in water temperature between the showerhead and your body and so-so force made this model mediocre.
 

Stand mixers

KitchenAid Classic K45SS[WH] and Sunbeam Mixmaster 2594 stand mixers
KitchenAid Classic K45SS[WH] and
Sunbeam Mixmaster 2594 stand mixers
In our tests of 18 models the KitchenAid Classic K45SS[WH], $200, at left, came out on top—a spot it has held for years—because it can whip up fluffy meringues and handle double batches of bread dough with ease. The Sunbeam Mixmaster 2594, $90, was a lightweight in performance and pounds.
 

Toaster ovens

Cuisinart TOB-195 and Emerson TOR35 toaster ovens
Cuisinart TOB-195 and Emerson TOR35
toaster ovens
The Cuisinart TOB-195, $180, at top, was very good at baking and broiling and toasts bread as evenly as some of the top toasters. It's spacious enough for a 4-pound chicken and has touchpad control. The Emerson TOR35, $70, was only fair at baking and took longer to bake and broil than other models.
 

Toasters

Cuisinart CPT-170 and Toastess Digital TT321 toasters
Cuisinart CPT-170 and Toastess Digital TT321
toasters
Whether you like your toast light or dark, the Cuisinart CPT-170, $80, at top, consistently produced batch after batch of evenly toasted bread, and a digital display counts the seconds until your toast is ready. The Toastess Digital TT321, $60, was only fair at toasting, and results were inconsistent from batch to batch.
 

Toilet paper

Quilted Northern Ultra Plush and Scott 1000 toilet paper
Quilted Northern Ultra Plush and
Scott 1000 toilet paper
Soft and strong, top-rated Quilted Northern Ultra Plush also disintegrated easily when flushed, so it's easier on plumbing and septic systems. It costs 29 cents per 100 sheets. Scott 1000 was the thinnest we tested and was only ­mediocre in strength and softness. It costs 6 cents per 100 sheets.
 

Toilets

American Standard Champion 4 2002.014 and Kohler Persuade K-3654 toilets
American Standard Champion 4 2002.014 and
Kohler Persuade K-3654 toilets
The American Standard Champion 4 2002.014, $425, left, provided power, quietness, and thorough bowl cleansing in one flush. The Briggs Maelstrom 4298, $230, clogged about half the time in our solid-waste test and needed multiple flushes. The Kohler Persuade K-3654, $325, right, got an even lower overall score; it has separate modes for liquid and solid waste.
 

For more Best & Worst products see our Laundry and cleaning & Home and garden reports.