Elliptical safety risk

 

Don't Buy: Safety Risk
Stamina 1725 (top)
Stamina 1772 (bottom)

This article is the archived version of a report that appeared in July 2009 Consumer Reports magazine. Visit our ellipticals page to see the very latest information on ellipticals.

Part stair-climber, part cross-country ski machine, elliptical trainers provide an all-body aerobic workout much like a treadmill does minus the impact on your joints. That is, when they work properly.

In our most recent evaluation of ellipticals, tested by 10 panelists, we found two models that posed a potential safety hazard. On the Stamina 1725 and similar Stamina 1772, bolts attaching the pedal arm to the drive-wheel assembly loosened, and came off in one instance. That put the user at risk of losing balance and possibly falling. We judged both models Don't Buy: Safety Risk, a new designation previously termed "Not Acceptable." (See the reasons behind that change.)

In late April, our Technical Division told Stamina officials about our findings. Stamina said it was aware of the issue and had updated its manual to instruct users to tighten the bolts before each use, an instruction we consider unrealistic. Additionally, Stamina said it had contacted the Consumer Product Safety Commission about the concerns. If you have one of those machines, stop using it immediately and notify the company at 800-375-7520 if you've had a problem.

We believe that ellipticals, whether idle or in use, pose a danger for children under 5. Owners should keep the machines where children can't get to them. Ratings of ellipticals will appear in a forthcoming issue and on ConsumerReports.org.