Subaru Impreza

The Impreza shot to the top of our small car rankings after its 2012 redesign, thanks to nimble handling, a roomy interior, improved fuel economy, and a comfortable ride that rivals some luxury sedans. All-wheel-drive, standard on all Imprezas, usually takes a toll on gas mileage, but we measured an impressive 27 mpg overall with the continuously-variable transmission (CVT.) Adults fit comfortably in the back seat, and the ride soaks up bumps with ease. Cabin noise remains an annoyance; updates for 2016 slightly improved that. Those updates also included a new touchscreen infotainment system, replacing previous antiquated offerings. Driver visibility and crash test results are top-notch. A rear camera became standard in 2015.

Redesigned for 2008, this generation of the Impreza became considerably more refined. It is a pleasant and practical car with one of the most comfortable rides of any small car we've tested. Improvements include more rear-seat room, a quieter cabin, and better fit and finish than the previous model. While its handling is still fairly agile, the Impreza isn't as sporty to drive as its predecessor. Standard all-wheel drive helps in slippery conditions, but saps fuel economy; fuel economy of 24 mpg overall with the automatic ranks among the least efficient small cars. Crash-test results are impressive; electronic stability control was a readily available option that became standard in 2009.

One of the better small cars, the Impreza serves up a supple ride and enjoyable handling. Paired with a well-tuned suspension, sharp steering makes the car feels agile and fun to drive. Standard anti-lock brakes and all-wheel-drive provide confidence in slippery conditions. Road noise can grow wearisome on longer trips. The 2.5-liter four-cylinder supplies decent acceleration, but 22 mpg overall is mediocre. Interior trim is relatively spartan, rear seat room is cramped, and trunk space is modest.

The Impreza offered sedan and wagon models from the start. Engines have always been "flat fours," four-cylinder engines whose cylinders are horizontally opposed. The 2.2-liter is livelier than the base 1.8-liter. The Impreza delivers nimble handling and a relatively comfortable ride. The rear seat is cramped and cargo space is tight. In 1996, AWD became standard on all Impreza models and an "Outback Sport" SUV-inspired wagon debuted.